When Warner Bros. adapted the seven Harry Potter novels into eight films, not every page made it to the screen. A recent discussion on r/harrypotter asked readers to share the missing moments they’d most like to see restored in the upcoming HBO Original remake. Fans offered dozens of suggestions, ranging from emotional character arcs to comedic highlights. Here are some of the most requested.
The Weasleys vs. the Dursleys’ Fireplace
One of the most-upvoted answers recalled Goblet of Fire, when the Weasleys attempt to collect Harry using the Floo Network. Unfortunately, the Dursleys’ fireplace is electric, causing chaos — capped off by Dudley choking on one of Fred and George’s bewitched toffees.
Petunia’s Howler and Backstory
Fans noted that Order of the Phoenix omitted the scene where Aunt Petunia receives a Howler reminding her of her connection to the magical world. The book also hints at her knowledge of Dementors and Snape’s history with Lily — moments that deepened her character.
Nearly Headless Nick’s Deathday Party
Several commenters called for the ghostly celebration from Chamber of Secrets, which introduces a fuller portrait of Hogwarts’ spectral residents. As one fan put it, “They had John Cleese and didn’t capitalize — criminal.”
Voldemort’s Job Interview with Dumbledore
From Half-Blood Prince, readers singled out “Lord Voldemort’s Request,” where a young Tom Riddle asks Dumbledore for the Defense Against the Dark Arts position. The tense exchange offers rare insight into their dynamic before Voldemort’s full transformation.
Dumbledore’s Funeral
One of the most emotional omissions from the films, fans said they still hope to see Fawkes the phoenix lament at Dumbledore’s funeral, as described in Half-Blood Prince.
Peeves the Poltergeist
Redditors expressed frustration at Peeves’ complete absence from the films, particularly scenes like the chandelier prank and his role in tormenting Dolores Umbridge. “I’m still salty about the general Peeves erasure,” one user wrote.
The St. Mungo’s Visit
Another Order of the Phoenix moment readers missed was Harry, Ron, and Hermione’s visit to St. Mungo’s Hospital. The chapter includes a meeting with Gilderoy Lockhart and a poignant reveal about Neville’s parents.
The Department of Mysteries in Full
Fans agreed that the Order of the Phoenix film cut down the surreal, eerie elements of the Department of Mysteries — including the brain room and the time-turning bell jar.
Harry and Dumbledore’s Confrontation
Several called for the complete version of Harry destroying Dumbledore’s office after Sirius’ death, a moment that underscores his grief and anger.
